Game 118: El Presidente vs. The King

gamelog.JPG In one corner, weighing 208 pounds, with an xFIP of 3.67, pitching for the Minnesota Twins, we have Johan "El Presidente" Santana.

In the other corner, weighing 230 pounds, with an xFIP of 3.19, pitching for the Seattle Mariners, we have "King" Felix Hernandez.

This could be a really great pitching matchup between two guy with effective but contrasting styles...or one of the pitchers could have a really bad night. No one knows that just yet.

Hitting lefty pitching is the Mariners' offensive forte. They have a .299/.354/.446 line against LHP so far this season, which gives them an OPS 11% better than league average against LHP. The Twins have a .265/.331/.391 line against RHP so far the season, which gives them an OPS 6% lower than league average against RHP, and basically sucks. There's a big difference between the lineup that Santana has to handle and the lineup that Felix has to handle.

A lot of the Twins' offensive suckitude this season has come in the second half of the season, where the Twins have "hit" .253/.308/.377 as a team. For comparison, Luis Rivas, in his career, has hit .262/.307/.383. Perhaps that best describes what it's been like to watch this team's offense since the All-Star break--it's like watching Luis Rivas hit over and over and over again. Sure, maybe he'll have a good night in KC, but mainly he's a waste of time.

As far as lineups and managers go, we'll see which manager can out-stupid the other. At least the Twins won't be facing a left-handed pitcher, so Gardy can't hit Tyner lead-off against a LHP, inciting me to run onto the field and strangle him as he hands over the lineup card to the umpires. (Though somehow I'll have to restrain myself as Gardy does just that on Wednesday.)

UPDATE: This might be McClaren's stupidest lineup ever! Felix Hernandez is an extreme groundball pitcher, one of the most extreme ground ball pitchers in the league, and he always has been. So what does McClaren do? He puts Jose Vidro at second base. Granted, Vidro's .330/.372/.379 this year looks decent, but he is slow as molasses and has already hit into 15 double plays this year. (Which of course makes him a great choice to hit second in the lineup.) More importantly, Vidro is absolutely terrible in the field.

His next brilliant idea is to put Willie "Boom-Boom" Bloomquist in for Adrian Beltre at 3B. Willie is not only an offensive downgrade from Beltre (who has a decent .286/.333/.429 line against Santana), he's a clear defensive downgrade from Beltre, who could well be the best defensive third baseman in the league.

Adam Jones gets the start in LF, which is probably McClaren's only good decision in this entire lineup. Sexson continues his sort-of-but-not-really platoon with Broussard (which is fine as Broussard isn't all that hot against lefties or very hot with the glove.)

My favorite part is that McClaren found a way to get Raul Ibanez in the lineup at DH. Ibanez is hitting .258/.280/.342 against LHP this year. For comparison, Jacque Jones has hit .228/.277/.348 in his career against LHP. Jose Lopez is having an awful year and is hitting just .237/.282/.333 against lefties, but that's practically as good as Ibanez. There was no need for McClaren to sacrifice Lopez's defense at 2B when he could have just put Vidro at DH instead of Ibanez.

Gardenhire has finally found a manager who can botch the lineup worse than he can. Wow. (Of course, Gardy counters by putting Tyner at DH and RonDL in LF, because he believes in pixie dust and all that. But really, at this point, Gardy has barely any choices to make.)

243 comments to Game 118: El Presidente vs. The King