SBG Nation Provides Your Daily Source for Half-Baked Crap

Your Basic Four Hour Commute

Posted by SBG on Saturday, January 19th, 2008 at 6:20 am

Thursday, as you may recall, was my birthday. As the day wore on, I was excited about the prospect of a nice birthday dinner at home with Lucy and BabySBG and kind just enjoying the day. I left the office about 5:15 and headed home. On the way home, my dad called. I answered the phone and he immediately started singing Happy Birthday. At the end, I said, you must have the wrong number... and he bought it! I said, no Dad, it's me, thanks! Enjoying the day. Anyway, I was talking with Dad as I drove east on Highway 62 and just as I crossed the Cedar Avenue bridge, I heard a noise that I recognized as coming from a flat tire. Shit.

Now, it was pretty cold out, but I figured that ten minutes of changing the tire would be a little uncomfortable, but not the end of the world. So, I got the baby spare out along with the jack and that jack handle/tire iron that you get nowadays. You know, the one with the socket that pivots on the end. You can fold the socket into itself and the socket is contained within a little bracket. It's a nice enough little tool.

Anyway, I was on the left hand side of the road and the flat tire was the left front. I jacked up the car, removed the lug nuts and I COULD NOT BUDGE THAT DAMNED TIRE. It would not move. Furthermore, when I grabbed the tire, I felt steel belts along the inside edge. Oh crap.

So, I called my dad and asked him what I should do. He suggested using the tire iron to beat on the tire. I did that, I kicked it and all I managed to do was bend the bracket so that the socket was stuck in the bracket, rendering the tire iron/jack handle unusable. Great. Now I've got a car jacked up with the lugnuts off the flat tire in front and I have no way of getting the tire off, tightening the lug nuts or lowering the jack.

tire-iron.jpg
Here's my tire iron with the socket snugly fit into its bracket

So, I call my wife and ask her for the number of the Tires Plus in Eagan. Now, there's also a Firestone store there, but they are crooks, as I have documented before. I asked them if they could come out and help me, but they said, no, they were busy and couldn't spare anyone. But, they referred me to Mark's Towing. Remember that name. Mark's Towing of Eagan, MN. They specialize in fucking over people who are stranded on the side of the highway in freezing cold.

I called Mark's Towing and told them that I was stranded on Crosstown and asked them if they could pick me up and tow my car to Tires Plus in Eagan. The woman I talked to said, yeah, sure. I asked how much and she said $75. I asked how long before they would get there and she said 20 to 25 minutes. I said, I'm in the car. She said that they would be right there.

Forty five minutes later, I called Mark's Towing again. I talked to some guy and I asked him where they were. He said that the truck had to go out and fix a tire at the airport and then he would be over. I said no, you are coming here right now. And he said, we have to help as many people as we can. I said, no you don't, you promised that you would help me and that you would come right out. (He's not the government, he entered into an oral contract with me and was now in breach of contract.) He said, I don't know what she promised you. I said, I'm telling you what she promised me. She promised me 20 to 25 minutes! I told him that since he hadn't lived up to his end of the bargain, I wanted a discount. He said that he couldn't do that. That's not surprising as he also couldn't live up to his word. I mean, if you tell someone in sub-freezing temperatures that you are going to show up right away, you had better show up right away! He said, why don't you just catch a ride home and we'll pick up your car later. What a jerk! I was plenty pissed off, so I told him that I might call the Attorney General's office and tell them how he does business. He said go ahead. That was an empty threat, but what I really intended to do was write this post so that when you Google Mark's Towing in Eagan, MN, this page comes up at the top of the list. And it does. And the blurb under the link says, "But, they referred me to Mark's Towing. Remember that name. Mark's Towing of Eagan, MN. They specialize in fucking over people who are stranded on the side..." So there, Mark's Towing in Eagan, MN, how do you like it? There's just so many ways this could have been handled. When I first called, they could have told me that they were busy (like say, the guys at Tires Plus) and it was going to be two hours or whatever, instead of saying we'll be right there. Or they could have told the guy with the tire it's going to be a while or whoever else they had hired on with. I could then been able to try someone else. When I called back, they could have apologized. They could have said, "l'll knock $20 off for your trouble." But, no. He didn't care about, you know, doing the right thing for a guy that relied on his company's promise. He just thought fuck it, I'm gonna make as much as I can by overpromising and leaving folks hang out to dry. Or freeze, as the case may be. What am I going to do, sue? Good luck with that. So, I hung up and called Lucy to see if she could find another towing company, one not run by assholes.

Just then, my savior arrived. It was a MNDOT guy and his truck said, I believe, Freeway Incident Team. I got out of my car, thinking it was the towing company (of course it wasn't them, they wouldn't show up for hours), but was relieved to see a state guy. He asked me what the problem was and I told him. He said, I know the problem. He got a rubber mallet out (and I'm buying a couple of those this weekend, one for each car) and pounded the tire right off. He told me that the salt causes the wheel to bond to the hub. He broke it free and changed my tire. He was an older guy, a retired Navy lifer and just as friendly as could be. I tried to tip him, but he told me that he wasn't allowed to take tips. I called Mark's Towing and canceled the tow, saving myself $75 (and probably more, since they apparently were in the business of not keeping their word and, based on this review, I'm probably right about that). A lot of people believe that the public sector can't do anything right and that the private sector is the only way to do things. Well, let me tell you. The private sector is filled with people like Mark's Towing in Eagan, who only care about maximizing profits without regard to the people who are paying them. By contrast, our Navy lifer was an example of service being provided by the public sector. Government's not perfect, but it isn't necessarily evil. Thank you, State of Minnesota. You really helped me out on Thursday night, and I appreciate it. Don't get me wrong. I'm not saying that the state should get into the business of towing cars (and hey, there's problems at MNDOT as anyone with access to a newspaper or the local news knows). But, what I am saying is that the attitude of state bad, private sector good is just a little too simplistic. A public servant like this Navy guy should be appreciated. He was doing his job and was cheerful and competent. And honest. I wish he'd have taken my money, but my respect for his integrity went through the freaking roof. When I fill out my tax return this year, I'll feel a little better about the state return. Having those guys out there keeping things moving is worth a few extra bucks, especially if I don't have to pay rude, contract breeching pricks like the folks over at Mark's Towing in Eagan, MN.

So, I drove over to Tires Plus and I got two new tires for the front. The one that was flat was badly worn, and it was clear, given the relatively low number of miles on the car, that the wheels were out of alignment, so I authorized an alignment. It was 7:30 by the time I got to Tires Plus and they said 45 minutes. So I called Lucy, who had prepared an absolute feast (Ribs and sauerkraut, mashed potates, Swedish meatballs, a delicious Pasta dish and a birthday cake that said "Happy 43rd Birthday, SBG" -- okay, she bought the cake, but the point is, it was there for me). I told her that I wouldn't be home until about 8:30. She was understandably upset -- she'd worked hard and she wanted to spend my birthday with me -- but this was the way it was.

bcake.jpg
The birthday cake's still uneaten.

I walked over to Caribou Coffee and got myself some hot chocolate. I asked if they had birthday specials and they said, "free drink with a coupon". Well, I didn't have a coupon, but they gave it to me anyway. :) I had a little lemon poppyseed bread, too, as I was getting hungry and I sat in there for about 45 minutes. I then walked back to Tires Plus, only to find that they hadn't even started on my car yet. Oh boy. I suspected when I walked over to Caribou that that might be the case -- they looked pretty busy. So, they overpromised, too, but at least they didn't leave me stranded on the side of the road somewhere. Well, some time after 8:30, the guy working there told me that there was no oil on my dipstick. What? I suppose I should check my oil more often than I do. And I suppose now I will do that when I fill with gas. But, the car has never been low on an oil change, so I was just assuming that it wasn't leaking or burning oil. The guy said that he'd change the oil (it was time) for $16.95. Good price (and $10 less than their regular price -- a discount? compared to Mark's Towing in Eagan, MN, these guys were business of the year!), so hey all's well.

At 9:15, they were done.

One wheel was severely out of alignment (damned potholes, fix them with my tax dollars!). Plus, they couldn't change my oil, because my drain plug was stripped and was loose. The last place that changed my oil was Valvoline on Cliff Road in Eagan, MN. They apparently effed up the drain plug. Can anybody provide decent service (other than that Navy lifer who works for MNDOT)? I used to change my oil all the time when I lived in ND -- it's not that hard to put a drain plug in! And Tires Plus did not have a replacement one to sell me! For Chrissakes! I must be living in automotive service Hell! So, they topped off my oil and sent me home. I arrived at home more than four hours after I left work, beaten down by a bad tire, bad service, and bitter cold. I had a couple of ribs, but the rest of the feast went into the refrigerator and will be leftovers.

Happy Birthday to me.


This entry was posted by SBG on Saturday, January 19th, 2008 at 6:20 am and is filed under Personal. It is one of 2370 entries by the author. We are no longer accepting Letters to the Editor on this post. Why?

27 LTEs

Moss
Moss replied on January 19th, 2008 at 9:29 am

Sorry, Bud. And happy belated birthday.

We owe a lot to civil servants (and especially military personnel). They make tremendous sacrifices to do good for the public. It's the bureaucrats and politicians that we could do without.

 
E-6
E-6 replied on January 19th, 2008 at 9:44 am

That's a pretty sh!tty birthday, boss. Hope yesterday was a whole lot better.

Oh, and get Triple AAA. At 59.00 a year, it's a bargain.

Moss
Moss replied on January 19th, 2008 at 1:17 pm

Little known secret --

Many auto insurance policies have an available rider for tow coverage. It's really quite cheap, much cheaper than AAA.

E-6
E-6 replied on January 19th, 2008 at 1:24 pm

Yeah, but wouldn't that require reading the policy?

Moss
Moss replied on January 19th, 2008 at 1:26 pm

It's not in the policy unless you sign on for the rider. You have to ASK the insurance agent for the rider. They don't generally include it unless you ask.

Moss hasn't had to invoke it, so unsure whether it will be a hassle or whether it will be worth it. Moss thinks you just call for a tow, pay, and submit for reimbursement.

SBG
SBG replied on January 19th, 2008 at 6:19 pm

Ooo, submitting an insurance claim? Sounds like a sure fire way to have rates jacked up.

 
Banjo
Banjo replied on January 19th, 2008 at 9:05 pm

Moss, do you recall if there is a length of tow limit with the rider? With AAA Premier, you get the 100 mile tow. We spend some time in the hinterlands, so the longer tow was an attractive option.

 
 
 
 
 
Beau
Beau replied on January 19th, 2008 at 10:25 am

One lesson I learned early in life with cars, is that you find some local guy with his own little shop that you can trust. And let him do EVERYTHING. Even oil changes. It's like having a doctor. You take your body to the same doctor if you can, because he'll get to know you and vice versa, and it's easier to trust someone to do a good job if you have a good relationship.

I have a guy who does everything on my car except tow it, and I let him recommend the towing company. I can't remember how many times I've gone in with a problem I thought was going to cost a lot of money and he told me it was really a two minute fix and didn't charge me for it.

I used to take my car to Valvoline, and that's like taking your body to a homeless guy in Calcutta who's screaming, "I'm a doctor!" and waving a stethoscope around. They are the epitome of everything that's wrong with the private sector.

Rhubarb_Runner
Rhubarb_Runner replied on January 19th, 2008 at 11:24 am

Even better, live next to a great neighbor who also owns a tire/service shop. The night before your service, park your car in his driveway and give him your keys. Lunchtime the next day, the car's back with the bill.

A couple months ago, we had a dead battery while at lunch after church one Sunday. My neighbor gave us a boost, followed us to his shop, and gave us a ride home, then got the battery changed the next morning in time for my wife to head to work. Can't beat it.

We have Motorist Assist here in StL, and every time I see one of those guys tooling along the highways or on the shoulder helping someone out, I feel a little more comfortable on my drive. Tax money well spent.

 
 
Banjo
Banjo replied on January 19th, 2008 at 12:13 pm

I subscribe to Beau's theory and have had great luck the past 5 years with our locally owned Precision Tune. Doug, the owner was the former service manager for one of the Walser properties. He's a tad chatty sometimes making it hard to get out of the store, but absolutely great customer service.

I let 'em do everything - Tires, Batteries, Brakes, Oil Changes etc. He's also great with women customers - ie. not condescending (my wife included) which is a real rarity. I get to hear all the horror stories from other shops - $1000 brake jobs (at Midas) and people getting royally screwed over by the chains.

As for the towing..a Triple AAA membership might come in handy too. For $75-100 a year you get to use their service. They have a pretty killer travel agency sevice which is nice for road trips and if you ever lock your keys in the car, run out of gas, etc. You're covered.

Algonad
Algonad replied on January 19th, 2008 at 12:43 pm

I agree on AAA. If you stay in hotels a couple nights per year, the discount you get more than pays for the membership.

 
Moss
Moss replied on January 19th, 2008 at 1:23 pm

Moss went into Precision Tune a few weeks ago to have brakes checked. They quoted over $520 and went into the "hard sell." Moss knows better than to sign on without checking.

First call -- Toyota dealer. Cheaper than the price quoted at PT, but not by a ton.

After a few more phone calls, Moss ended up choosing the local Kennedy Transmission (within walking distance) and they did the brakes (with new rotors), a transmission flush and an oil change all for about $300. Moss has had him quote some other jobs, and he is very competitive compared to others.

So in theory Moss agrees with Banjo, but in practice, Moss will not be going to PT for any work.

Banjo
Banjo replied on January 19th, 2008 at 1:37 pm

PT's are franchises - so the quality of the work and service can vary between locations. We got lucky. What I like about our shop is the owner is behind the counter everyday. You might not get that with some of the bigger franchisees, or perhaps they are just a bunch of ass-clowns.

I know I have benefited by the loyalty to the shop. He's benefited too because of my repeat business on repairs and my purchases of consumables, like tires.

Moss
Moss replied on January 19th, 2008 at 3:05 pm

Kennedy's a franchise too. Luckily, the guy Moss deals with is the owner of the shop. That's always the best situation. Moss got lucky too.

Moss has had some good luck at Tires Plus even...

brianS
brianS replied on January 19th, 2008 at 6:33 pm

We had been going to the local Les Schwab ("Free Beef"), thanks to a personal connection to the then-assistant manager. Great service, even though the then-manager was an incompetent idiot, because our friend was The Man.

Unfortunately, he moved to become manager of his own store, which required an equity investment on his part. After months of work putting together the staff and prepping the store for opening, he was fired suddenly and without warning, thanks apparently to some serious shenanigans going on within the company (our interpretation, obviously, but the guy is the most honest, competent car repair guy I've ever dealt with). Within a day, he had something like sixteen job offers from other stores in the chain.

you just never know what you're gonna get with a franchise operation.

 
 
 
SBG
SBG replied on January 19th, 2008 at 6:17 pm

Kennedy Transmission in Eagan gets a qualified seal of approval. Had a transmission problem with the Explorer. Had a new transmission put in -- lasted two weeks before complete failure. They replaced it with no charge and no questions asked. Next day, huge puddle of transmission fluid under the vehicle. They fixed again with no charge and no questions asked. So, they stood behind their work, which to begin with was faulty.

 
 
 
New Britain Bo
New Britain Bo replied on January 19th, 2008 at 12:22 pm

Mark's Towing === Making Worst.

 
ubelmann
ubelmann replied on January 19th, 2008 at 3:07 pm

If it's any consolation, I thought it made for an interesting story.

I tend to agree with your position on private/public sector. Neither is perfectly good or perfectly bad, and it's important to remember that when trying to find the right balance between public and private.

 
brianS
brianS replied on January 19th, 2008 at 6:13 pm

What I want to know is, where's "the face" on your cake? I thought ubelmann established that "the face" should be a must tradition :-)

SBG
SBG replied on January 19th, 2008 at 6:20 pm

All complaints should be directed toward Lucy. I'm going to suggest that you think twice about making such a complaint.

brianS
brianS replied on January 19th, 2008 at 6:34 pm

baseballs and candy. She da Bomb!

*retreats hurriedly to a remote corner*

 
 
 
twayn
twayn replied on January 19th, 2008 at 6:51 pm

SBG, when you get those rubber mallets, get a pair of jack stands as well. Put one in each car. Before you use the rubber mallet to knock that stuck tire off, position the jack stand so that if the jack shifts as you pound, the jack stand will catch the car. Better yet, lower the car onto the jack stand before you start pounding. It's much more stable and a lot safer.

 
KeithG
KeithG replied on January 20th, 2008 at 1:05 am

"So I called Lucy, who had prepared an absolute feast (Ribs and sauerkraut, mashed potates, Swedish meatballs, a delicious Pasta dish and a birthday cake..."

I count three entrees in that feast...two for you and one for MLK?

SBG
SBG replied on January 20th, 2008 at 7:49 am

There was a lot of food. I'm going to be eating leftovers for some time.

 
 
bjhess
bjhess replied on January 20th, 2008 at 10:58 am

You inspired me with your previous post in this vain. Thus my "Clements Auto Mankato Sucks" post was born. It used to be #6 on a Google search for "Clements Auto Mankato". Now it's nowhere to be seen. Come to think of it, my blog, in general, is not getting the juice it used to. Wonder what's going on?

My auto insurance includes a towing package. But it's just a reimbursement. So I find the towing service, and they'll reimburse up to $50. It's not a normal claim, so rates aren't effected. I think it costs around $2/year/car.

 
Kyle
Kyle replied on January 22nd, 2008 at 6:40 am

If you find yourself with car problems in the Northeast Metro, Larson's Automotive on Country Road D and White Bear Ave (right near the Maplewood Mall) is an honest establishment. My family has been going there for years. If we need something we know they can't do (bodywork for example), we let them refer us to another shop they trade business with and have always gotten a Larson's discount.

As far as public sector, my main issue is the lack of transparency and the lack of creative distruction. How much are we really paying for the Freeway Incident Team, how many people are they serving, and even if the cost is too high we can't opt out, whereas I doubt anyone that read this post will ever give a cent to Mark's Towing.

None of that means the guy from MNDOT isn't ten times the human being any of the employees of Mark's Towing you dealt with are.

Rhubarb_Runner
Rhubarb_Runner replied on January 22nd, 2008 at 7:29 am

Larson sounds like a honest, upstanding name ;)

 
 

Sorry, The WGOM is no longer accepting Letters to the Editor on this article.

=