Hey, another award that Jeter can't take from Mauer. This season, Mauer was 54.9 weighted Runs Above Average (wRAA). If you combine the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th best-hitting catchers in the AL (Victor Martinez, Jorge Posada, and Mike Napoli), you get 55.2 wRAA.
Limiting ourselves to catchers hitting in the AL, it is a dead heat between Mauer and a three-headed monster of Victorge Posapoli.

So you're saying this Joe guy is good.
Him and Victorge Posapoli.
Victorge is definitely not as good-looking as Mauer.
I think that is a criterion for the Silver Surfer Award.